Tag Archives: litigation

Information Quality – Every Little Helps

[Thanks to Tony O’Brien for sending this one in to us recently. For those of you not familiar with Tesco and their marketing slogans, this is their corporate website.]

ManagementToday.com has a great story (from 25th November) of how six bicycles purchased by Tesco from a supplier came with an apparent£1million (US$1.62 million) price tag.

Some red faces at Tesco HQ this morning, after news emerged that Britain’s biggest supermarket accidentally paid one of its suppliers almost £1m for six bikes.

The unit cost for each bicycle turns out to be a whopping £164000 instead of the usual £164.

While the majority of the money was repaid, the trouble for Tesco is that they are engaged in a dispute with the supplier in relation to other matters so the supplier has held on to 12% of the money. So Tesco have called in their lawyers. Which means that the total cost of failure will inevitably be much higher by the time the whole mess is sorted out.

Of course, simple consistency checks on data entry could have trapped that error and saved Tesco money and embarrassment.

It seems that with Information Quality, as with Retail Grocery, every little helps.

Dublin bank bungled foreign exchange transaction (in 2001)

Following on from this morning’s story about the New Zealand overdraft fiasco, a few further cases of Information Quality trainwrecks in Financial services have come to our attention.

This first one is from 2001 and was found on the BBC.co.uk website, with further reporting from The Telegraph

Bank bungles pesetas/euros

Back in 2001, David Hickey was emigrating from Ireland to Spain. He asked his bank to change IR£1500 into pesetas, but an error in the bank meant that the  amount transferred was in euros, not pesetas. IR£1500 was approximately 300,000 pesetas. Mr Hickey received EUR300,000 into his account.

The bank eventually had to take legal action in Spain to freeze Mr Hickey’s accounts with a view to getting the money back.

At the time, the bank declined to comment further to the media on the matter and the Irish police were of the view that no criminal offence had taken place because of the ‘technical error’ (i.e. IQTrainwreck) involved.

Other Trainwrecks

We’re researching the other IQTrainwrecks that came to light this morning on this theme, not least to make sure we haven’t covered them here already. Expect further updates in the coming days.